How to Choose High-Quality Supplements (and Why It Matters)

Walk into any store—or scroll through Amazon—and you’ll see hundreds of supplement options, each claiming to be “the best.” It’s confusing even for professionals. The truth is, not all supplements are created equal.

Some are made to pharmaceutical-grade standards. Others are mass-produced overseas, mislabeled, or contaminated. Understanding how to choose high-quality supplements can protect both your health and your wallet.

The Quality Problem in the Supplement Industry

Unlike prescription drugs, supplements in the U.S. are not required to prove safety or effectiveness before they reach store shelves. The FDA regulates them as food, not drugs.

That means:

• Companies can market a supplement without pre-approval.

• Ingredient lists are often incomplete or inaccurate.

• Independent testing sometimes finds less—or more—of an ingredient than the label claims.

• Some products contain heavy metals, fillers, or hidden pharmaceuticals.

A 2023 review found that up to 25% of supplements tested did not contain the labeled ingredient or potency. Another 10–15% were found to contain undeclared ingredients or contaminants.

So how do you find the real thing?

What Makes a Supplement “High Quality”

Look for these key indicators before buying:

1. Third-party testing. Reputable brands submit their products for independent lab verification (for purity, potency, and contamination).Look for seals like NSF Certified, USP Verified, or ConsumerLab approval.

2. Transparent labeling

   • Full ingredient list

   • Strain numbers for probiotics

   • Standardized extracts (e.g., “curcumin 95% curcuminoids”)

   • Clear dosing instructions and expiration dates

3. Professional-grade manufacturing. Brands that sell through healthcare channels (like Fullscript) are often held to higher GMP—Good Manufacturing Practice—standards than retail or Amazon-only sellers.

4. Scientific rationale. Choose formulas based on clinical research, not trends or influencer hype. Avoid exaggerated claims (“boosts immunity overnight” or “cures everything”).

5. Storage and handling. Supplements can lose potency with heat, humidity, and light. Professional suppliers maintain climate-controlled storage and direct shipping to preserve product integrity.

Why “Amazon Reviews” Aren’t Enough

Amazon is convenient—but it’s not a regulated pharmacy.Many supplements on marketplace sites are third-party resold, meaning they might be stored improperly, close to expiration, or even counterfeit.

Positive reviews can be misleading:

• Most consumers can’t verify purity or potency.

• Some reviews are incentivized or fake.

• Many reviewers only rate packaging or shipping speed—not product effectiveness.

You deserve better than crowdsourced medicine.

A Smarter Way: Using a Vetted Source

This is why I use and recommend Fullscript—an online dispensary that carries only vetted, practitioner-grade supplements.

Fullscript partners exclusively with healthcare professionals, so you can:

• Access brands that meet GMP and third-party testing standards

• Order directly from the manufacturer (no middle-resellers)

• Get storage, dosing, and safety guidance from your practitioner

• Track all your supplements in one account for reorders and refills

It’s not about “selling supplements.” It’s about ensuring patients get what the label claims, at the potency that works, with purity that’s proven.

How to Apply This to Your Routine

When you evaluate or start a supplement, ask:

1. Why am I taking this? (What is the goal?)

2. Is there evidence that it works for that goal?

3. Has it been tested for purity and potency?

4. Does my practitioner agree it’s appropriate for me?

If you can answer yes to all four, you’re already ahead of 90% of supplement buyers!

By Dr. Kim Drolet

*Interested in looking at Fullscript’s catalog? Sign up here. Free. No obligation.